V. OTHER RESOURCES II
(1) Under our current grant, NPPR is developing a compendium of data
collection "best practices," e.g., surveys and other instruments,
calculators and translators, policies, etc. They have already gathered
dozens of examples, and a workgroup including such experienced hands as
Terri Goldberg, Cindy McComas, John Calcagni, and Kirk Mills is going
over them. The plan is to put the best practices up on the web later
this Summer, and perhaps to follow up with training.
(2) There are several session of interest at next week's Summit in New
Orleans. Among others:
-- On Monday (unfortunately during the same time as the Regional
meeting), there is training titled "Measuring P2 Results: Data
Collection Tools and Techniques," conducted by Terri Goldberg, Cindy
McComas, and Ken Grimm.
-- On Tuesday at 4:30, I'm moderating a session entitled "P2 Results
Data Collection: How to Get the Numbers." The panel is made up of
experienced state, local, and private sector folks, who have put
together an integrated presentation covering drivers for measurement,
identifying data, collecting data, and using it.
(3) The National P2 Results Data System includes common P2 metrics and
integrated data bases run by the 8 P2Rx centers to collect consistent
data from a variety of sources. The 30 states who have signed MOAs to
participate are starting to populate the system with numbers from 04 and
05. Ken Grimm, Andy Bray, and Kirk Mills will give an update on the
System in New Orleans on Wednesday at 2:00.
(4) There's a good discussion of data collection at the P2Rx Topic Hub
for Environmental Measurement, managed by PPRC. It has a nice step-wise
approach for measurement, and a wonderful list of resources. It's
accessible at:
http://www.pprc.org/hubs/subsection.cfm?hub=1000&subsec=13&nav=13
(5) Last year, EPA issued "Guidelines for Measuring the Performance of
EPA Partnership Programs." It incorporates (in Appendix E) the P2
"common metrics" and definitions developed by the P2 Results Task Force
and used in the National P2 Results Data System, as a model. You can
find this document at:
http://intranet.epa.gov/partners/guidelines/measurement_guidelines.pdf
(6) Finally, there are a series of calculators and guides to calculators
that the group developing Measurement Guidance for P2 Regional
Coodinators have discussed. Here are some examples:
(a.) A set of calculators developed by the Pacific Northwest Pollution
Prevention Resource Exchange (PPRC) which enable the user to estimate
the cost savings created by implementing P2 activities. These
calculators convert such P2 results as air emissions or hazardous waste
reduced into dollars of reduced operation costs. See "Calculator Data
2004" at this link:
http://www.p2rx.org/services/measurement.cfm
(b.) Rob Guillemin asked an intern to develop the attached draft
document listing 53 "On-Line Calculators, Tools, and Resources that
Measure, Track, and Evaluate Pollution Prevention Activities." It is
included in the current draft of our Measurement Guidance for Regional
P2 Coordinators.
(See attached file: On-line P2 Calculators 1.0.doc)
(c.) The Federal Electronics Challenge (FEC) and related programs have
developed a calculator to come up with various environmental outcomes
from electronic stewardship actions. The FEC data entered (from their
annual reports) include the number of EPEAT registered products
purchased, percentage of computers/monitors/laptops with ENERGY STAR
enabled, average lifespan of computers, and number of
computers/monitors/laptops reused and recycled.
The calculations and equivalents come from the Electronics Environmental
Benefits Calculator (EEBC), which is finally available on the FEC Web
site (as an Excel spreadsheet):
http://www.federalelectronicschallenge.net/resources/bencalc.htm
The
EEBC lists all of its assumptions and references, which were validated
in an independent peer review. The EEBC can take any one or more of the
above data points and provide environmental benefits and equivalents.
(d.) The EPP program in our Division developed a guide to a number of
tools that can be used to quantify the benefits of green purchasing.
It's available at:
http://www.epa.gov/oppt/epp/tools/epp_metrics.pdf
(e.) At the excellent P2Rx topic hub on environmental measurement, there
are references to a number of software and electronic tools. That's
available at:
http://www.p2rx.org/topichubs/bibliography.cfm?hub=1000&subsec=100&nav=100&Resource=Y#Software/electronic%20tool
(f.) Andy Bray of NEWMOA shared a series of CO2 emission calculators
for specific sectors and cross-sector activities put out by the
Greenhouse Gas Protocol Initiative.
http://www.ghgprotocol.org/templates/GHG5/layout.asp?type=p&MenuId=OTAx&doOpen=1&ClickMenu=No
For those in agricultural areas, this reference includes data such as
methane emissions and other climate change impacts of livestock.
http://www.virtualcentre.org/en/library/key_pub/longshad/a0701e/A0701E03.pdf